The Real Reason Spring Housing Sales Are Falling Apart (And It’s Not Just Rates).
This spring, all eyes are on the housing market. National articles point to high mortgage rates, stubbornly high home prices, and a tight inventory as the usual culprits for a slowing real estate market. While these macroeconomic factors are certainly real, they miss a critical shift that’s quietly reshaping the dynamics between buyers and sellers: the shift in how buyer’s agent commissions are paid.
For the first time in recent history, buyers are now responsible for paying their agent’s commission out of pocket. In the past, it was common practice for the seller to cover both their agent’s commission and the buyer’s agent commission, usually a total of 5–6% of the sale price. This new reality has placed a heavy burden on buyers, and it’s having an outsized impact on the market, especially this spring.
How We Got Here
Historically, buyer’s agents have been compensated through the seller’s proceeds at closing. This was seen as a fair trade: the seller pays for the marketing and commissions, and the buyer has a down payment and is qualified for the loan amount. While this formula worked in most cases, it was unsettling for sellers to pre-determine what they would pay a buyer’s agent without knowing their experience, reputation, or offer terms, and knowing their role was to negotiate the lowest price and most concessions from the seller. The decoupling of commissions was long overdue. These recent regulatory changes, lawsuits, and evolving market practices have shifted the responsibility to the buyer’s side. This means that, in addition to coming up with a down payment, paying for closing costs, and covering repair or update expenses, buyers now also need to budget for their agent’s commission, typically 2.5–3% of the purchase price. Buyer’s agents can request a seller concession as part of the buyer’s written offer, but it’s not guaranteed, and it may not match the commission the buyer originally agreed to pay their agent when they began their home search. That might not sound like much at first glance, but when you do the math, it adds up quickly. For a $500,000 home, a 3% commission means $15,000. That’s on top of the down payment (often $25,000 or more), plus closing costs (another $5,000–10,000), and any immediate repairs or updates.
A Real-Life Example
As a Certified Probate & Trust Realtor and one of the top 5% of agents at my brokerage, I work with a wide range of properties, everything from fire-damaged homes to $1 million estates on golf courses. Because I often represent successor trustees and attorneys, I see the real-world effects of pricing, negotiation, and market shifts in a way few agents do. The following example is just one of many that shows how the new commission structure is changing today’s market.
I recently worked with a client who experienced this shift firsthand. We listed a property and received an offer $15,000 over asking and asking for a $15,000 seller credit and a 3% buyer’s agent commission. I called the buyer’s agent to clarify the offer and asked what the buyer planned to use the requested seller credit for. I wanted to understand if it was for repairs, loan costs, or something else, so we could anticipate their strategy for future negotiations.
The buyer’s agent stated that the seller’s credit was earmarked for loan and closing costs, but not repairs. We countered with a $7,500 seller credit and a 2.5% buyer’s agent commission, knowing that we would still need to negotiate repairs. The buyer’s agent responded by saying they would increase their offer by $10,000 but also increase their seller credit request by $5,000. Why? Because the buyer still needed to cover the full 3% commission they owed their agent, and they couldn’t make the numbers work without additional seller credit.
In the end, the buyer canceled the transaction. They simply couldn’t make the math work. What made the situation more concerning was that, although the buyer’s agent said they would agree to a 2.5% commission in the counteroffer, their agent was still trying to recover the full 3% by increasing the seller’s credit request. It felt unethical, essentially forcing the seller to cover the buyer’s full agent commission through a backdoor method. Since the deal fell through, we’ll never know how that payment would have been handled or even disclosed. This isn’t an isolated case. I’m seeing variations of this more and more. Buyers, especially first-timers or those already stretching financially, are overwhelmed by the growing burden of down payments, repairs, and now, their agent’s commission.
The Unseen Impact on the Market
While headlines focus on high mortgage rates and affordability challenges, this shift in commission structure is quietly adding yet another barrier to homeownership. It’s cutting into negotiation flexibility. If buyers need seller credits just to cover their agent fees, it leaves less room to negotiate repairs, price reductions, or other incentives.
For sellers, this creates a tough balancing act. Even with competitive pricing and strong marketing, if buyers can’t piece together the financial puzzle, deals fall apart. Sellers may need to offer additional credits or concessions just to keep deals alive, ultimately pushing home prices downward or extending days on market.
This spring’s slowdown isn’t just about macroeconomics; it’s about a structural shift in how real estate transactions work. Buyers who might have stretched their budgets in previous markets are hitting a hard ceiling when they realize they need to cover their own agent fees. The result? More cancelled transactions, fewer offers, a softer-than-expected market, and lower prices, especially in what’s traditionally a busy season,
What Can Buyers Do About Buyer Agent Commissions?
With the recent changes to how buyer agent commissions are handled, it’s more important than ever to carefully consider who represents you in a real estate transaction. All too often, when someone is buying or selling a home, they call a family member or throw a friend a bone, even if that person lacks experience, because, hey, “we know real estate,” right? How hard could it be? But with the new compensation rules and legal responsibilities now at play, this isn’t the time for casual choices. You wouldn’t hire your friend to represent you in court or perform surgery if they weren’t the best, so don’t make that mistake in real estate.
These changes were long overdue. For years, buyer’s agents have worked tirelessly researching listings, showing homes, writing offers, and driving all over town, often without any guarantee of compensation. However, if a buyer feels unsure about the process or worried that something is being missed, there are a few key points to consider. First, buyers are now required to sign a Buyer Representation and Broker Compensation Agreement (BRBC), which is only valid for three months. If the buyer feels uneasy after signing the agreement and the broker refuses to cancel it, the buyer can let it expire. But, before signing, buyers should review a few key terms:
(1) Is the agreement exclusive or non-exclusive? If it’s exclusive and the buyer later decides to work with a different agent, they may still owe commission, even if the original agent wasn’t involved in the purchase.
(2) Buyers can check a box indicating they don’t have sufficient funds to pay the broker, making the broker’s compensation contingent on the seller’s agreement to pay.
(3) If the seller’s offered compensation is lower than the buyer’s agreement, the buyer and agent can sign a Modification of Terms to match it. Be sure to discuss this upfront with your agent and ask: “Will you modify our terms if the seller doesn’t agree to cover your compensation?”
Another option buyers are exploring is working directly with the listing agent. This can be a smart strategy if handled properly. Buyers should interview the listing agent to ensure they’ll be treated fairly. The California Association of Realtors has already anticipated this trend, and the most recent listing agreement includes two lines for compensation: one for listing the home and another for the listing agent’s services if they also work with the buyer. In this case, the buyer may work with the listing agent under a Buyer Non-Agency Agreement, which means the agent still represents the seller but is allowed to assist the buyer with fair dealing, disclosures, and access to information. Because the seller has already agreed to compensate the listing agent fully, the buyer avoids having to pay a separate commission.
Finally, if a buyer wants their agent to be flexible on fees, it’s only fair to be respectful of their time. Once escrow opens, most agents will spend 30 to 40 hours on the transaction. In the early stages, consider previewing open houses and grouping showings into a single trip. Avoid unnecessary requests that could cost your agent time and money, especially if you’re hoping for commission flexibility in return.
Looking Ahead
As we move through this transition, it’s critical for buyers, sellers, and agents to understand the new landscape. Buyers need to factor in agent commissions early in the process and get creative with financing and negotiations. Sellers need to recognize that even with a strong marketing plan and attractive pricing, today’s buyers are navigating a tougher financial path that will ultimately impact the final sale price.
And as for the market overall? This shift is creating friction that macroeconomic factors alone can’t explain. The real story of this spring’s market slowdown is about the hidden financial strain on buyers, a strain that’s reshaping how deals are made, negotiated, and, too often, abandoned.
###
Eric McCormick is a Certified Probate & Trust Realtor with London Properties and the owner of Estate Sale Fresno, offering full-service estate liquidation to “Sell the House & Everything In It.” Ranked in the top 5% of agents at London Properties, Eric combines real estate expertise with compassionate transition services for families, attorneys, and successor trustees. London Properties operates with over 340 Sales Associates and support staff across nine offices and ranks in the top 1% of all brokerage firms in America. Cal BRE# 01931027